Statehouse Republicans passed two major policy changes Wednesday that would restrict both medication-induced and surgical abortions.
The legislation was pushed through on one of the final lawmaking days of the two-year legislative session. It also marks the GOP’s first significant legislative change on the subject since Ohio voters amended the state’s constitution in 2023 to guarantee women a right to abortion access until the point of fetal viability without “burden” or “interference” from the state.
Democrats say both bills violate the new constitutional amendment on their face, a question that will likely be answered by the courts. Legal advocacy groups like the ACLU have promised a swift lawsuit challenging at least one of them if Gov. Mike DeWine signs the bills into law.
Stricter rules on doctors prescribing mifepristone
The first bill passed Wednesday, House Bill 324, would establish new, stricter rules on doctors who prescribe drugs on a federal list that includes mifepristone, an abortion-inducing medication. The language would require an in-person appointment for a prescription – the drug is commonly prescribed remotely today via telehealth visits.
The other bill, House Bill 347, would essentially resurrect Ohio’s 24-hour waiting period, which women must undergo after seeing a physician who documents their “informed consent” before they can receive an abortion. The current law has been blocked by the courts.
If signed into law, the bill would require doctors to tell women about the medical risks of abortion – which medical groups say are low and overstated by the bill’s backers – along with “alternatives to abortion, including adoption and parenting.”
Republicans framed the legislation as educational and protective of women in nature and not in violation of the new constitutional amendment. Democrats said the bills are not only unconstitutional but also could lead to health complications that can stem from pregnancy.
“It’s not so much ‘interferences and burdens’ as it is looking out for patient health, patients’ informed consent, allowing the patient to have the conversation about the procedure or the drug they’re about to take and make an informed decision based on that,” Senate President Rob McColley, a Republican, told reporters on Wednesday.
Republican leader argues 24-hour waiting period ‘not overly burdensome’
House Speaker Matt Huffman, the Republican in control of the chamber’s agenda, described the waiting-period requirement as “informational” and said it doesn’t violate Ohio’s voter-approved constitutional guarantee of abortion access.
“A 24-hour waiting period, something like that, the bill anticipates that that’s not overly burdensome,” he said.
Democrats say the laws violate Ohio’s constitution, which prohibits laws that directly or indirectly burden or limit women’s access to abortion, miscarriage treatment and other forms of reproductive health care.
Sen. Beth Liston, a Democrat and a physician, spoke out against both bills. She said they both arbitrarily impose a new set of rules on pregnant women that don’t exist anywhere else in medicine. For instance, she asked, why not pass a law requiring doctors to tell men about the risks about vasectomies?
Sen. Bill DeMora, also a Democrat, suggested Republicans are acting like sore losers and passing bills that will almost certainly be blocked by judges.
“All these bills that keep getting introduced and debated go completely contrary to what the voters wanted,” he said.
ACLU promises ‘imminent’ lawsuit if bill is signed
Speaking to reporters, House Minority Leader Dani Isaacsohn made similar comments, noting Republicans’ sweeping losses during election season.
“It is the most backwards response to such an overwhelming defeat at the hands of voters just a few weeks ago,” said Isaacsohn, the ranking House Democrat.
Speaking about the 24-hour waiting period, Jessie Hill, an ACLU attorney, promised an “imminent” lawsuit if the bill is signed.
“Ohio Republican lawmakers are completely out of touch with the will of the voters, who overwhelmingly supported the Ohio Reproductive Freedom Amendment in 2023 and rejected government overreach at the ballot box just two weeks ago,” she said.
Planned Parenthood Advocates of Greater Ohio called on DeWine to veto both bills.
“These bills threaten reproductive freedom and would create new government interference in abortion care and decisions that should be left to patients and their healthcare providers,” the organization said in a call to action.
