When Cleveland filmmaker Laura Paglin first visited Pike County in 2017, her plan was to make a documentary about the Rhoden family murders. At that point, more than a year had passed since eight members of the Rhoden family were killed in the small Southern Ohio enclave, and the police had yet to make any arrests.

“After a whole year had passed, I just got to thinking, how could a crime of this magnitude in such an intimate community not be solved?” Paglin said.

As she settled into life in the Village of Piketon — population 2,011 — Paglin became much more interested in the stories of the everyday people she met. 

The result of Paglin’s time there is her new documentary, “This is Pike County.” The film looks at life in the rural Appalachian community and the struggles its people contend with. 

While Paglin’s documentary addresses the murders, they are part of a larger story. Through her lens, the viewer sees what the residents deal with: drug addiction, poverty, the decommissioning of a former uranium enrichment plant and the creation of a $650 million hazardous waste landfill.

Today, Pike County is in the news for another reason: If all goes as planned, it will soon be the site of a massive data center.

Headshot of Laura Paglin, director of "This is Pike County."
Director Laura Paglin at the 2016 Greenwich International Film Festival on June 10, 2016, in Greenwich, Connecticut. Credit: (Mark Sagliocco/Getty Images for GIFF)

The Nightlight will host a sold-out screening of “This is Pike County” on Sunday, followed by a Q&A with Paglin.

We spoke to Paglin about her documentary.

In your past work, have you gone down this true crime path before?
Before this, I had done a film called ‘Unseen’ that looks into the [Anthony] Sowell murders, the serial killer in Cleveland. I’m not someone who’s interested in, inside the mind of the serial killer and all that. I was really more interested on a societal kind of level.

This was a bit different. I quickly realized, ‘Oh, I can’t really focus on the murders.’ I did interview some of the grieving family members, but I didn’t want that to be the focus of the film. While I was there, I was staying at the Piketon Motel. I got to know some of the people, and I realized, ‘Oh, this is more like a residential hotel.’ A lot of people staying there were kind of [at] a crossroads in their lives and struggling. So that’s where I met the little girl, Lily [Lawson] and Brittany [Lyn Lemaster], the young mom who’s struggling with addiction. Later as I stayed there, I learned about the uranium enrichment site. I’d known nothing about that. So I decided to make it more like a portrait piece.

You realized that you couldn’t focus on the murders. What made you come to that conclusion?
When I got there, it hadn’t been solved. And I thought, OK, well, short of talking to these family members, everyone was pretty much baffled as to what happened. There’s only so far you can go with that. It’s not like the murderers are going to come out and let me interview them. So it was really more this kind of grief hanging over the community. 

Lily, the young girl you met early on, is a throughline in the documentary. Why did you decide to focus on her?
She was staying at the motel, and I think when she saw me with the camera, she really just — you could see her there. She wanted to pretend that she was a news reporter and she’s showing me around the motel, and pretty much she started bossing me around. [Laughs.] ‘Let’s go here,’ and ‘We could do this.’ I think she was a little lost in her life there. You can see it in the film, and her family situation at the time was pretty chaotic. So she welcomed my presence both for the attention and the company. There are many times off screen where she would ask me to take her somewhere, do something fun. So we did do a lot of that as well. She’s just such a bubbly kid, and you can see she’s really hungering for new experiences and wants to see more of life and enjoys talking to people.

Watching your film, there’s so much working against this town, but there are also these lovely moments of levity and of people finding joy. What do you want people to know about Pike County after watching the film?
I know it’s kind of a dark film, but I want them to see that it’s also a place worth fighting for. It’s just as you said: You could see the caring that people have for each other, despite the problems. And also to think about how what we do in this generation affects the next. You have the current generation struggling with forces beyond their control or situations that were not of their making, including the former enrichment plant, which brought a lot of economic stability, but then left generations of people with horrible cancers. We need to think about that because that former enrichment plant is now going to be the site of [a large] data center.

The people you’ve kept in touch with, what are their thoughts on it? 
I think it is kind of a combination of, this could be good because they are struggling economically. It’s not just the data center. They’re going to be building these power lines to power it. If it goes ahead, it’s gonna tear through people’s farmland. And so there’s a lot of concern about that. It’s not even just Pike County; it’s neighboring counties. They want to get that thing powered up as quickly as possible. So I know some people are fighting that already.

I do know it’s driving up property values. You could say, well, that could be a good thing, but then you have all these struggling poor people there who aren’t going to be able to afford the rent. … I haven’t really dug into that yet. But I was actually hoping to stop by there soon and look into that. Some people have asked if I’m going to do a sequel.

Are you?
It’s too early to commit. Maybe it’s a film for someone else. But I’m tinkering with different ideas, so we’ll see.

Culture & Arts Reporter (she/her)
Brittany is an accomplished journalist who’s passionate about the arts, civic engagement and great storytelling. She has more than a decade of experience covering culture and arts, both in Ohio and nationally. She previously served as the associate editor of Columbus Monthly, where she wrote community-focused stories about Central Ohio’s movers and shakers. A lifelong Ohioan, she grew up in Springfield and graduated from Kent State University.