In an effort to circumvent Akron City Council, a coalition of local leaders is aiming to collect 5,000 signatures by Aug. 25 — in hopes of adding a charter amendment to November’s ballot.

If successful, the ballot initiative would allow Akron residents to vote on whether they want the Akron Police Department and Akron Fire Department to consider internal and external candidates for chief and deputy chief positions, instead of just internal candidates.

The effort has faced stark opposition from the police and fire unions. The police union accused the charter amendment effort late last week of bringing “politics” into public safety, even citing an argument against diversity from far-right political commentator Matt Walsh.

Late last month, Akron City Council voted 7-4 to reject legislation proposed by Akron Mayor Shammas Malik to place the amendment on the ballot. The signature effort, announced on Monday, is the last path available to change the books during this election cycle. As of Tuesday afternoon, more than 50 people had signed up to help distribute petitions and collect signatures. 

Judi Hill, president of the Akron chapter of the NAACP.
Judi Hill, president of the Akron chapter of the NAACP, told Deputy Chief Brian Harding during a town hall at East Community Learning Center on Tuesday, April 23, 2024, “I want to hear from you, what are you going to do differently?” if he was selected as Akron’s new police chief. (Susan Zake / Signal Akron)

Supporters of the charter amendment say it will create a stronger and more diverse pool of candidates in the wake of a police chief hiring process where only two APD deputy chiefs, both white men, were allowed to be considered. Akron NAACP President Judi Hill lent her support to the charter amendment effort, saying in a statement that it’s the “right step for the right time for our community.” 

Council Member Eric Garrett said that, for years, Black officers were intentionally kept out of the top ranks of the department. Garrett added that changing the law is necessary so the next generation of Black men have someone to look up to in the department. 

Rev. Ray Greene of The Freedom Bloc said, “It allow(s) diverse upward mobility in our Public Safety Forces and instill(s) trust in our community by allowing the community to weigh in and offer perspectives to benefit the process, building understanding and collaboration between the community, local government and our safety force.”

Malik, State Rep. Veronica Sims, State Rep. Vernon Sykes, and University of Akron Lecturer Heather Pollock lent their support as well.

The charter amendment would supersede the previously, little-known state law that Malik’s law department discovered earlier this year amid a national search for a new police chief. The law states that only internal candidates can be considered for the chief and deputy chief positions in the city’s fire and police departments. 

The amendment would add language to the city charter to supersede the previously ignored but now strictly followed state law. 

Black leaders previously upset by Akron police chief hiring process

Malik’s insistence on shutting down a national police chief search in favor of only internal candidates drew the ire of Black elected officials and community members upset that only two white men — deputy chiefs Brian Harding and Jesse Leeser — would be considered. 

Malik chose in May to hire Harding, who was serving as interim chief when Malik took office in January, instead of waiting until after a charter amendment could be passed in November. Still, the mayor supported placing a charter amendment on the ballot. 

Meanwhile, in June, Leon Henderson, a Black man, was hired as the chief of the AFD in an internal-only hiring process. 

Collecting signatures: Who are the local leaders behind the charter amendment effort?

According to the charter amendment, the Akron residents responsible for it include:

  • Robert DeJournett, a prominent pastor at St. Ashworth Temple Church of God in Christ, which Jayland Walker’s family has long attended
  • Willa Keith, a retired sergeant with the Akron police 
  • Lathardus Goggins, an educator and advocate for at-risk youth
  • Barb Greene
  • Rev. Shannon Blower, a local chaplain 

Among other things, the charter amendment would also formally add future police and fire chiefs to the mayor’s cabinet and require the mayor to create a diverse pool of candidates representative of the city. 

Union: ‘Tell everyone you know not to sign’

The signature initiative upset the Fraternal Order of Police Akron Lodge #7 — the police union — and its president, Brian Lucey, who released a statement on Friday. Without naming her, Lucey criticized the promotion of Sierjie Lash within the fire department, implying she is unqualified to be district chief and was elevated because she is a Black woman.

Calling to “keep politics out of policing,” Lucey highlighted a quote from far-right political commentator Matt Walsh: “Once you start emphasizing anything other than merit, skill, and competence in the hiring process bad things will follow.”

Walsh wrote that quote in an Instagram caption, blaming Boeing’s mechanical failures on the company’s apparent diversity initiatives — a common right-wing trope — instead of cost-cutting efforts and flawed regulatory processes.

Lucey, who did not return multiple requests for comment, told Malik to “please re-read” Walsh’s quote “and share it with your HR department.” 

In a Facebook post on Tuesday, the union said it heard signature gatherers will be at the PorchRockr festival Saturday in Highland Square.

“Don’t sign,” the post said. “Tell everyone you know not to sign. Also educate people on why this is bad for the city and the morale of the department.”  
The campaign needs 4,862 valid signatures (10% percent of the electors, based upon the total vote cast at the last preceding general municipal election, according to the Ohio Attorney General’s website) by the Aug. 25 deadline.

Government Reporter (he/him)
Doug Brown covers all things connected to the government in the city. He strives to hold elected officials and other powerful figures accountable to the community through easily digestible stories about complex issues. Prior to joining Signal Akron, Doug was a communications staffer at the ACLU of Oregon, news reporter for the Portland Mercury, staff writer for Cleveland Scene, and writer for Deadspin.com, among other roles. He has a bachelor’s degree in political science from Hiram College and a master’s degree in journalism from Kent State University.

For routine messages, feel free to contact Doug Brown at doug@signalakron.org. If you have privacy concerns and/or want to share sensitive information, you can reach him on the end-to-end encrypted messaging app Signal (no connection to Signal Akron) under username @dbrown.2010 and encrypted email account db159@proton.me